TN: I tried to use different words for regression cause it does get repetitive... zzz
※This takes place before regression
"Do you really think that 'reversing time' is truly 'unlimited', Sensei?"
"What?"
Angelina's innocence, pleaded by, of all people, Shulk, who was reliving his life, left Niel speechless.
"At first, when we knew nothing, we fell for Merc. She only ever accepted us half-heartedly, since Prince Leonhardt is her true love. And we, growing frantic for her attention, ended up seeing Angelina-sama as an enemy, because Merc was wary of her... Cute, isn't it? She's so guarded, so suspicious, and she thinks we haven't noticed. She even kept asking Carlos-san about Angelina-sama, over and over."
Niel averted his eyes.
That's right. She didn't realise that she was openly guarded.
She thought she was hiding it. That's really all there is to it.
It was almost endearing, how shallow, how foolish.
"It'd be funny watching it from a distance."
"... Funny?"
Shulk raised his right hand and began counting off on his fingers, one by one.
- Merc is harmed by someone. ↓
- We ask her if she has any idea who it might be. ↓
- Merc clearly has someone in mind, but only deflects. ↓
- Bothered by it, from her easy-to-read expression, we work out who she suspects. ↓
- Come to think of it, she'd been concerned about Angelina for quite some time. ↓
- Angelina has been bullying Merc for much longer than we thought.
In fact, she might have been bullied for over half a year, ever since Carlos first started enquiring into Angelina's behaviour.
That's when we begin to think it's Angelina.
"... Something like that."
"That's..."
"'I never realized she'd been suffering all this time.' 'Angelina has been doing such cowardly things behind our backs. Unforgivable.'"
Niel furrowed his brow.
"Our own helplessness, and our outrage at the treatment of the girl we'd come to love. And then... I suppose our disappointment in Angelina-sama. We didn't feel that strongly about her, but there are people who genuinely expect a lot from her and believed in her. When that flipped, it became less about caring for Merc and more about not being able to contain our anger against Angelina-sama. Carlos-san was one of those who were furious with her."
Niel pressed a hand over his mouth, struggling to control the intense urge to shout back and deny what Shulk was saying.
He had to listen to Shulk, who had lived this life before, in earnest.
For if he was driven by that rage to choose time regression... they ran the risk of being trapped in an "infinite loop."
That was why his past self had refused a "redo with no one's memories intact."
... If that came to pass, in the worst case, it would send them all the way back to "the very starting point."
So someone had to return with their memory.
Otherwise, "they would simply repeat the same thing."
Even so, there should have been a "safety mechanism" in place to prevent Merc, the very focal point of the magic, from becoming exhausted.
If only Merc hadn't held the belief that turning back time was perfectly normal...
Niel stared at Shulk in cold sweat.
"We're merely recreating the 'magic that the former Alstroemeria royal family once used'. We've constructed the theory, but it's something that relies solely on the artifacts possessed by the royal family."
"Ah, that's true."
"Then, 'could the previous royal family rewind time freely?' 'If that were the case, then it should have been impossible for them to fall.'"
"...!"
The previous royal family had been destroyed. But they don't know how Merc's ancestors managed to preserve their bloodline.
But they had ceased to be royal. Even though they had possessed 【Time Reversal Magic】.
"... Is there some kind of 'restriction' engraved on that artifact?"
"Probably. And the destruction of Alstroemeria couldn't be prevented because of that restriction."
"Then..."
"That's right. That's probably the reason why we keep 'failing' no matter how many times we try. The Time Reversal Magic 'cannot be used without limit.'"
Was it predetermined that they would fail in this life?
No. That couldn't be.
"... I think some past version of me and you had already worked that out at some point."
"What...?"
"That's why 'we kept Merc out of the loop'. Merc's happiness must have been the most important thing to us, who were willing to go back in time."
After a brief pause, Shulk continued.
"--- 'Those of us who redid things will surely fail.' We'll end up regretting reversing time. That's probably the restriction placed on Time Reversal Magic. Someone has to draw the short straw for time to rewind, which means only we who started over will fail."
Niel was speechless again.
"That can't be. Then..."
"For time regression to 'succeed,' a sacrifice is necessary. But it doesn't mean we'll necessarily 'go through the same thing all over again'. That's why this game must allow you to 'retire' partway through. You could call it a compromise. A compromise on happiness. Even if the goal isn't achieved, this life is enough. If we can compromise and give up, the journey through time should have ended, without repeating over and over. But no one would give up. And that brings us to the present."
Shulk let out a sigh.
"I guess it was a mistake for me, you and Merc to all be together in the same period. We ended up reconstructing 'it'. We ended up reviving Alstroemeria's legacy. Convinced that it was for Merc's happiness, we reached this magic, and tried to start over, to 'reset.' We have the ability to do it after all. Then there's Prince Leonhardt."
"His Highness?"
"... He won't give up on Merc, will he? And he could easily discover Alstroemeria's magic. The royal family probably still has a record of this magic."
"Ah, that does seem likely. So that's why. That's why Prince Leonhardt brought this up with me."
The starting point. All the pieces had fallen together far too easily.
So, was it inevitable that someone would reach that conclusion? And so, the journey through time began.
"...Then should we just give up on our own accord? If we don't help then reversing time should be impossible in the first place..."
"That would probably be meaningless too."
"What?"
"Unless we stop Merc and Prince Leonhardt, the only requirement for activating the magic is the artifact... besides..."
"Besides?"
"... Even before she ever met us, Merc knew 'a spell that was passed down through the Alstroemeria royal family.'"
"!?"
This time, Niel was truly stunned.
Because that spell was something that he had only managed to uncover after years of research. That was how lost it was.
"Why!?"
"Who knows. Perhaps her parents passed something down to her. Or perhaps for some other reason entirely. In any case, unless we stop Merc and Prince Leonhardt, the reversal magic will be cast even without our help. In that case, wouldn't it be better for us to guide it ourselves?"
"No... well, it is. But wait. If we have that knowledge, we could simply keep Merc away from those outrageous circumstances..."
"That's impossible."
Shulk cut him off flatly.
"Why...?"
"Because my memory of the crucial parts gets fuzzy. Or because something comes up that I can't handle in time. Or because she gets caught up in a separate matter."
"...! The artifact's restriction."
"Exactly. It's not that we can't change the things that fail, it's because fresh problems just keep sprouting up. That's why things have turned out like this. And well... I hate to say it, but... Merc is a daydreamer."
"What...?"
"I wonder why. Whenever she gets together with Prince Leonhardt, she lets her guard down. 'It's fine now,' 'I worked so hard,' 'It'll be all right,' 'Don't worry'... As if that's any way to survive in noble society. And so she fails. Her vigilance drops to zero. Even this time, she messed up because of that, didn't she? It's as though she's convinced she's invincible against anyone except Angelina-sama. Even though that's obviously not true."
Niel recalled Merc's recent words and actions... Shulk's points were on the mark.
If she weren't the woman he had fallen for, she would be exhausting to put up with.
Hardly the conduct one would expect of the Crown Prince's fiancée, of the future queen.
He figured she was just giddy about being with her lover.
He thought it was just a phase. But that in itself proved fatal.
"You asked who had set Merc up, whether it was Angelina-sama, didn't you? I'll tell you, Niel-sensei. The culprits, in past iterations, have included the royal family, Duke Lordic's house, and there have been marquess houses involved as well. And occasionally, other noble houses too."
"... That many?"
"Mn. Especially the Lordic house... they've been burnt by Merc for ages."
"Burnt?"
"Academically. Sandika-sama was always ranked below Merc, wasn't she? Losing to Angelina-sama would be one thing, but for a duke's daughter to keep losing to a former-commoner like Merc seems to have really gotten to her. Apparently her family was pressing her about it too. Actually, if you look at it objectively, it was Sandika-sama, not Angelina-sama, who should have come under suspicion for the bullying."
"Sandika..."
"That's right. Merc was surrounded by enemies. That's why she was bullied so much at the Academy. And it was hard to gather evidence, because everyone was conspiring together... And the proof that comes to light implicates Angelina-sama. I suppose that suited everyone's purpose. By making her the 'villain,' Prince Leonhardt, his aides, us, and Merc herself were all 'satisfied.' Just the right person to pin everything on."
It was at that point that Niel finally went pale.
He had been bluntly told that he had stolen the future of an innocent young lady.
It was too late to undo what had been done.
"... Then, what do we do? To stop the time loop, do we have to kill Merc, or Prince Leonhardt?"
"Kill them? Both of them are royalty now, you know. If we did that, our own lives would be over... And somehow I doubt that would actually work, either. It would just become a new 'cause' for the time loop. If the Prince came close to being killed, the King would surely find a way to use this magic."
"... So the time loop can't be stopped?"
"Hmm. I think we're all just trying to figure out how to stop this loop, aren't we? While also being selfish enough to insist on a 'happy ending' on top of that. We haven't managed to find the compromise point yet."
"But doesn't the 'restriction' exist?"
"Mn. It does. But, I find it strange that the 'price' is that we absolutely cannot be happy."
"... What?"
"Because this is the magic of the Alstroemeria royal family, isn't it? So what's engraved on the artifact is, at the end of the day, a 'restriction,' not a 'price.' In other words, a 'route' to a happy ending... surely exists."
A route. To a happy ending.
"And I've come to realise that the key to that might be... Angelina-sama."
"Angelina is?"
Shulk nodded and stared intently into Niel's eyes.
"'Time may only be rewound for the sake of what is right.' Otherwise, those who redid things will surely come to regret it."
For the sake of what is right. Was that the hidden restriction of Alstroemeria's magic?
"We reached this conclusion at some point, and yet we still mistook what 'the right thing' was. We believed that the right thing to do was drive away anyone who hurts Merc. But we were wrong from the beginning. That's why we failed over and over again and kept regressing."
In other words.
"The one who should be saved is not Merc. It is Angelina-sama... We should have considered that and started over. Otherwise, this time loop will never end."